That’s how understanding becomes understandable and polite in everyday life.
And only then can we discuss whether I stand by you too. Probably not at the moment. I’m clearly, and by three digits, too heavy.
Still, language has a lot to do with plain standing. When I understand, I’ve sailed past the dark cliffs of the incomprehensible. Although actively wanting to understand is a most strenuous affair. Especially for the world of synapses I sometimes worry whether they’re not overtaxed. After all, at some point I want to be able to say: “Yes, I’ve understood.” I don’t need any more standing than that.
No, exertion isn’t harmful, so long as it comes with moderation and one or two goals along the way. Naturally, the sternness buried in the word “exertion” bothers me. Sometimes that sternness produces more intensive thinking, enough to arrive at an acceptable result.
That, at least, was a fact until now. Then came the machine, wanting to take exactly that off our hands: the strenuous part, the not-understanding. We can all breathe a sigh of relief and focus on real life again. That is, amuse ourselves, fret, despair, and leave the search for understanding to the machine once and for all. Because the machine stands by convoluted thinking, pondering, researching, and formulating proposals understandably.
Congratulations, humanity. You’ve excused yourself from your own homework.
Yes, there are voices who see this very capacity for thought as being in danger. Outsourcing thinking is pleasant and convenient, sure, but I don’t stand for it. If I give away this one thing that makes Homo sapiens Homo sapiens — do I lose the thinking I trained into myself with such effort? I believe: yes. And that worries me more than any machine.
I’m old. I still experimented with floppy disks, with a Commodore computer. Back when computers were seen as incomprehensible and mystical. But from mere looking, nobody will ever understand — and then also operate — that tin or plastic thing.
Back then too, the results spat out onto paper were first regarded with astonished credulity. After all, the fast wonder-thing had filled many pages of paper with knowledge. Knowledge? Or just ink that looked like knowledge?
I grew suspicious when I bought such a thing for my company. “Your life will be easier from now on, and you’ll have more time for yourself.” Such promises are really more like compromises. That’s as far as I understood marketing back then. The other gigantic claim was “the paperless office.” The forest immediately begged to differ. After all, more trees lost their crowns than before the computer showed up with its buddy, the printer. And I remember very well certain calculation results that delivered imaginative strings of numbers but no facts. Computers aren’t human, but they make mistakes all the same. And how. The computer never apologized for the wrong figures. That, at least, is something AI has grasped — when you question the result with “are you sure,” and AI serves up the data again, altered — and above all, different.
Well, thanks a lot. At least I still apologize for my mistakes.
I stand by it — by my own mind, however small it may be. I like it all the same. Because thinking itself leads to better understanding. That’s why it’s often simply called the mind. On rarer occasions, it even earns the addition “common sense.”
Is AI — Artificial Intelligence — likewise labelled with “healthy AI sense”? Or even rated as trustworthy?
Whoops. And hold on a moment. How are we humanists even supposed to recognize whether AI appears worthy of any trust at all? After all, the aforementioned common sense is just puttering along on its own. What isn’t used falls asleep. And what’s asleep eventually stands dead still.
Of course it’s tempting to send off any number of tasks to AI and start by hoping for its understanding. But something is missing here, to a great degree. A machine spits data, explanations, and stories at and out to us that we, with or without our own minds, never arrived at ourselves. So what’s my hitherto common sense to do now that it’s lost most of its job? Will it turn to boredom, or even to drugs — like Lazy Slow Dumbness (LSD)?
No, this isn’t a condemnation of artificial intelligence as such. What bothers me more is the fundamental trust placed in a machine’s imitation of human behaviour and thought. It turns me from a thinking being into a mere consuming one.
“Hey AI, I stand by you. Sometimes.”



