In Hamilton, Ontario, 175 steelworkers got the famous blue envelope these past weeks. As so often, the drama lies in the fine print. This time it came steel-hard – straight from the employer.
Thanks for the comment. Let me get this straight. You haven’t seen the contract, you’re going by news reports, and the verdict is already in. That isn’t criticism. It’s a trial where the judge reads the headlines and skips the file.
Redactions are a fair point. I’d take them seriously if you brought specifics. Which clauses? Which amounts? Who applied the redactions, under which rules, and which comparable contracts were handled better? “Not transparent” is a feeling. A blacked-out line item is a fact. You gave me the feeling.
You also say “without transparency, no trust; no trust, nothing she says can be believed.” That’s a neat chain, and it proves too much. By that logic nobody’s word counts unless you’ve personally audited it, including the news outlets you rely on for your own case. You can’t call your sources reliable and the other side’s word worthless in the same breath.
Then there’s “stop giving away money we don’t have.” Which money, how much, and to whom? What would you cut, what would you do instead, and what does it cost? A slogan has no budget line. Action counts, not party. I don’t care if it’s red, blue, orange or polka-dot. I care what gets done, and whether anyone can check it.
Slogans are free, Steven, and worth every cent. Good critics bring a proposal along. If you have one, send it. I’ll read it carefully, and I’ll argue with it if it’s wrong. If you don’t, the comment goes into the “Forget it” folder. It’s well organized, and it’s getting rather full.
The contract is not in my hands.
The news outlets, all I have to go by, state that the contract is full of redactions.
The Liberals, our government as a whole, has a poor track record when it comes to being transparent.
Without transparency there can be no trust.
No trust means nothing she says can be believed.
I say, stop giving away money we don't have.
Steven,
Thanks for the comment. Let me get this straight. You haven’t seen the contract, you’re going by news reports, and the verdict is already in. That isn’t criticism. It’s a trial where the judge reads the headlines and skips the file.
Redactions are a fair point. I’d take them seriously if you brought specifics. Which clauses? Which amounts? Who applied the redactions, under which rules, and which comparable contracts were handled better? “Not transparent” is a feeling. A blacked-out line item is a fact. You gave me the feeling.
You also say “without transparency, no trust; no trust, nothing she says can be believed.” That’s a neat chain, and it proves too much. By that logic nobody’s word counts unless you’ve personally audited it, including the news outlets you rely on for your own case. You can’t call your sources reliable and the other side’s word worthless in the same breath.
Then there’s “stop giving away money we don’t have.” Which money, how much, and to whom? What would you cut, what would you do instead, and what does it cost? A slogan has no budget line. Action counts, not party. I don’t care if it’s red, blue, orange or polka-dot. I care what gets done, and whether anyone can check it.
Slogans are free, Steven, and worth every cent. Good critics bring a proposal along. If you have one, send it. I’ll read it carefully, and I’ll argue with it if it’s wrong. If you don’t, the comment goes into the “Forget it” folder. It’s well organized, and it’s getting rather full.
Christian